US court rejects Apple’s plea to quash lawsuit against Tim Cook for withholding China sales information

US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers’ decision late Monday night clears the way for shareholders led by a British pension fund to sue over a one-day plunge that wiped out $74 billion of Apple’s market value.

The lawsuit stemmed from Cook’s comment on a November 1, 2018, analyst call that while Apple faced sales pressure in markets such as Brazil, India, Russia and Turkey, where currencies had weakened, “I would not put China in that category.”

Apple told suppliers a few days later to curb production, and on Jan. 2, 2019, unexpectedly slashed its quarterly revenue forecast by up to $9 billion, blaming US-China trade tensions.

The lowered revenue forecast was Apple’s first since the iPhone’s launch in 2007, and the Cupertino, California-based company’s shares fell 10% the next day.

Rogers, based in Oakland, California, said jurors could reasonably infer that Cook was discussing Apple’s sales outlook in China, not past performance or the impact of currency changes.

Discover the stories of your interest

The judge also said that prior to Cook’s comment, Apple knew China’s economy had been slowing and had data suggesting that demand could fall. “A reasonable jury could find that failure to disclose these risks caused plaintiff’s harm,” Rogers wrote.

Apple and its lawyers did not immediately respond on Tuesday to requests for comment. Lawyers for the shareholders did not immediately respond to similar requests.

The lead plaintiff is the Norfolk County Council as Administering Authority of the Norfolk Pension Fund, located in Norwich, England.

Apple’s share price has approximately quintupled since January 2019, giving it a market value near $3 trillion.

The case is In re Apple Inc Securities Litigation, US District Court, Northern District of California, No. 19-02033.